20 September 2014

Prodigal Prophets and Faithful Foreigners

“I knew you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to relent from punishment.” Jonah’s words fly out of his mouth as an accusation, a charge against God.

Jonah wanted justice. He wanted things to be put right, and he wanted God to be the one to make it happen. Nineveh was the capital of the neo-Assyrian empire – the people who had exiled the Northern Kingdom in 722 BCE. They burdened the Southern Kingdom with heavy taxation. They deserved what was coming to them.

But Jonah still didn’t want to go. He went the opposite direction instead. The faithfulness of the sailors, praying to their gods, heightens Jonah’s unwillingness to do what God asked him to do. In the belly of the fish – he was as good as dead – he had some time to reflect on his situation. Jonah says, “As my life was ebbing away,
                        I remembered the LORD;
            and my prayer came to you,
                        into your holy temple.
             Those who worship vain idols
                        forsake their true loyalty.
             But I with the voice of thanksgiving
                        will sacrifice to you;
            what I have vowed I will pay.
                        Deliverance belongs to the LORD!”
So he is spewed on dry land and goes to Nineveh. His one-day walk would have hardly gotten him to the center of town, and I’m guessing he spoke his five-word sermon under his breath. And the people of Nineveh repent, contrary to all expectation. 

And God changed God’s mind, and Jonah loses it. “I knew about you, God.” “I knew about you and your forgiving ways.” “I knew it.” “I could have just stayed home. The storm, the belly of the fish, all of that suffering that you put me through, and this is it?!?”

“Is it right for you to be angry?” God asks, and I imagine Jonah storming out of the city. Fine, God. At least you’re going to stick to your word, right? Justice still happens, right?

Sometimes, it’s really easy to confuse vengeance and justice. It’s even easier to call our ideas of vengeance justice and to place God in the service of our desires and ideas of how to set the world right. Our desires to make the world right by hitting the bully back harder, by finding just the right word that will cut through the smug look on our opponents’ face, are exposed when we come face to face with what is, evidently, God’s idea of justice. Most of us don’t want to admit how satisfying an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth feels. Most of us don’t want to admit that we are happy to receive God’s grace, mercy, and love and how terrible we are at sharing it… especially with our enemies.

The shade and comfort of the bush having been removed from him, Jonah once again becomes angry. “Is it right for you to be angry about the bush?” God asks. “Angry enough to die.” I don’t want to live in a world where such injustices exist. I don’t want to live in a world in which the justice of God means injustice for me. I don’t want to live in a world where God doesn’t do what I want God to do and act the way that I would have God act. And so we confuse the roles between Creator and created, thinking that God’s capacity to show mercy and to forgive is similar to ours.

“I knew that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to relent from punishing.”

Everyone in Jonah is faithful – except Jonah. He sleeps while the sailors pray. He never repents of having disobeyed God while the Ninevites proclaim a fast and repent. He wants God to be on his side, and he thinks that God being on his side means that God will do to Nineveh what Jonah would do to Nineveh.

What Jonah misses is that, all along, God is on his side. Sometimes God-for-us comes into the world as God-against-us, insofar as God refuses to allow our understandings of grace, mercy, and love to be God’s understandings of grace, mercy and love. God exposes our tendencies to represent vengeance as justice. Sometimes the only way that God can be for us is to be against us, by exposing our tendencies to take matters into our own hands, to act in the name of God without first considering what God has to say about the matter.

The grace, mercy, and love that Jonah is so unwilling to share is the very grace, mercy, and love that Jonah takes for granted, all the while not realizing that God has already saved his life three in the story: once from the belly of the whale and twice from his own self-righteousness.

God’s grace, mercy, and love never come to those who deserve it, and they rarely come on the heels of our good behavior. They come at our lowest point, when we’re in the bottom of the belly of the whale, when we’re blinded by self-righteous anger and indignation.

“I know that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love, and ready to forgive.” It is a charge. It is an accusation. It is God-for-us even as God says “no” to our schemes to make ourselves into gods and cast God into our image.

The grace of God offends our imaginations. The mercy of God extends beyond our capacity to forgive. God’s steadfast love holds us fast in our anger, in our bitterness, and in our hatred. It is big enough to cover a prodigal prophet, who insists that grace, love, and mercy be deserved, and saves him in spite of himself – in spite of his own undeserving. Fortunately, God’s idea of justice is far different from ours; it is the justice that declares the sinner has been made righteous, that proclaims the prodigal is beloved, that repeats – again and again – that it is never too late to find your way home.










No comments: